How Not to Keep Score

by Alisa on January 11, 2012

We should have named her, "Trouble."

My husband was leaving for a business trip. He bent down to kiss me. As I kissed him, I griped, “When you get back, you better pick up the slack with this new puppy.”

“What slack?” he said, taken aback.

“It’s just like I thought it would be when I said I didn’t want another dog. I’m the one doing nearly everything. I’m feeding the puppy. I’m walking the puppy. I’m playing with the puppy. I’m training the puppy. And I’m cleaning up the puppy’s poop and pee. This was not supposed to be my puppy.”

“What? I walked the puppy today,” he said proudly.

“How many times?” I sneered.

“Once,” he said, not as confidently.

“I walked her twice,” I said.

“How many times did you walk her yesterday?” I pressed.

And it went on like this, even though I knew better.

Conversations like this are rarely productive.

They’re not because my husband and I have different scoring systems. It doesn’t matter how much evidence I throw in his face. He’ll always feel as if he’s pulling his weight, even if I think he’s not.

Case in point: This past weekend, I spent an entire day being a mom, being a dog owner, and being a home Goddess. I got up at the crack of dawn to walk the puppy. I cleaned up the puppy’s accidents three or more times. I looked through macaroni and cheese recipes with my kid, had her pick one out, and went to the grocery store together to buy the ingredients. I paid bills. I straightened the house. I listened to my kid whine as we both walked the puppy at a nearby park.

I stopped the puppy from chewing on nearly everything in the house.

This is the husband, shown with the dog who likes to pee by my desk.

During all of this time, my husband was sleeping, off at work, running personal errands and watching television.

Around 6 pm I was in the kitchen making macaroni and cheese. I’d already boiled the elbows. I had all the ingredients measured out. I have the casserole dish ready and the oven pre-heated.

I had just poured the milk into a pan and started heating it when the husband came in and said, “You’re using THAT much cheese?”

“I’m following a recipe,” I said. “That’s what it calls for.”

He read the recipe. He obviously didn’t think I was capable of following a recipe without his help. He’s like that. I’ve written about how he’s a back seat cook, so this should not come as a surprise to you.

“You don’t have Gouda cheese,” he said.

“The store doesn’t sell pre shredded Gouda. I made some substitutions. It will be fine.”

He examined my cheese choices. He decided one of them wasn’t good enough. He put it back in the fridge and took out a container of pizza cheese instead.

As I said, he’s like this. I used to blow my top when he would do things like this. Now I just roll my eyes.

Sometimes I laugh, but not this time.

On this day I had a cold and the puppy had worn me out. So I was already grumpy by the time I boiled the first elbow.

He started adding cheese to the milk. That’s when I left the room. I am not a back seat cook.

Later he and our kid got in a fight over who was going to watch what on TV. She called him a lazy bum. He sent her to her room. Later when he asked her if she was sorry, she replied, “No, you are a lazy bum. All you do is watch TV.”

He said, “I am not lazy! I just worked hard cooking dinner and I find it really annoying when you call me lazy!” And he added more time to her room sentence.

I found his response interesting. My first thought was, “You cooked dinner?”

My second thought was, “You thought you were working hard when you were telling me how I should be cooking dinner and when you completed the last two steps of the recipe I’d already almost finished?”

I didn’t say any of this out loud. I just found it amusing.

For some time, my mind was quite busy with score keeping. I mentally added up all of the things I do around the house on a regular basis: 80 percent of the cleaning, 80 percent of the grocery shopping, 90 percent of the cooking, all of the bill paying and budgeting, all of the investing, all of the accounting, all of the mail sorting, most of the home organization, all of the kid’s medical appointments, most of the homework supervising, nearly all of the dog walking and all of the putting away of various things, especially laundry.

I thought about what he does: all of the yard work, all of the fixing of various broken things, most of the laundry, occasional cooking, occasional cleaning, some dog walking, some kid supervision.

My list is a lot longer than his list, isn’t it?

I also began tallying a different list of free time. Most days my husband had enough free time to hang out with his friends, ride his bike for hours, and camp out on the sofa while he watches motorized vehicles travel in circles on television.

On the other hand, I usually have just enough free time to squeeze in a 30-minute run and a 10- or 15-minute meditation if I’m lucky.

But this kind of score keeping isn’t helpful. It’s not because my husband has a similar list in his head and according to his list, he does more.

His list is wrong, of course, but that’s beside the point.

It’s pointless to argue about who does more because such an argument doesn’t get you anywhere. It doesn’t solve any problems and it doesn’t make anyone feel any better.

Sure it might lead to a fleeting feeling of superiority, but that’s about it.

What would have been much more productive for me to say to my husband as he was leaving on his trip was this, “I’m already exhausted and I’m sure I’m going to be even more so by the time you return. When you get back, can you schedule in more home time so you can help me find more me-time?”

That kind of question would have gotten me somewhere.

In any relationship, happiness never comes from keeping a mental tally of who does more of what. Happiness comes from asking for support when you need it, from letting go of the small stuff, and from championing your spouse when he wants an atta boy for cooking the last quarter of a meal.

I know this. I’ve known it for a long time. This led me to wonder why I regressed and started keeping score again this weekend.

I blame it on the puppy. During times when free time is plentiful, it’s easy not to keep score. It’s more tempting, however, when I feel stressed, tired, worn out, out of shape, or neglected. When I don’t have enough time to care for my own needs—to sleep, to exercise, to meditate—I get grumpy and I start keeping score.

Until we got this puppy, I had just enough time for me. Once the puppy came into my life, not so much.

It’s similar to sustenance. At a family meal, if there is plenty of food on the table, no one notices how much anyone else eats. On the other hand, if there is not a heck of a lot of food on the table, people start keeping score, saying things like, “Hey, you have a bigger scoop of ice cream than I have. Not fair!”

In the end, the solution isn’t about fighting over scarcity. It’s in finding a way to create abundance.

Score keeping is fighting over scarcity.

Problem solving is how you create abundance.

Do you keep score in your relationships? Have you overcome your need to keep score? How? Are there times when you think score keeping is necessary? Why or why not?

Related posts:

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

{ 17 comments… read them below or add one }

Kathy January 11, 2012 at 4:16 pm

My husband and I don’t keep score. We use to compare how tired we are – a form of score keeping. We now just agree that we are both overly tired, since who’s to say who’s more tired.

One thing that did help on the “tired” was us watching a show about sleep deprivation. He learned a LOT. I knew all about it since I’d been living it.

It helps that we don’t share in the household chores – I’m a housewife, he earns the money. I know I do all the cooking, since that’s not on his “to do” list. He doesn’t even do the dishes if I’m sick. They wait until I’m well. But if I’m not cooking, he picks up dinner. He’s recently been informed why I don’t cook dinner on the nights I go to Happy Hour – because it adds to my “happy”.

Reply

Susan January 12, 2012 at 10:10 pm

Agree! The “I’m more tired than you” game is not helpful, but for two competitive partners, it feels almost inevitable.

Alisa, you’re so right about the scarcity vs. abundance thing, and I think that conflict is at the root of most arguments. I love that coined the term “backseat cooking.”
Susan´s last [type] ..May I Pick Your Brain? The Classic Freelance Quandary

Reply

Alexandra January 11, 2012 at 8:07 pm

I enjoyed my trip to visit my son because suddenly I had nothing to do but play with grandchildren and it made me realize how much I usually do on a daily basis. I don’t keep score by any means, but it does rankle after a while, you’re right. I can see how a new puppy would make you go over the edge.
Alexandra´s last [type] ..Methods of Wellfleet Navigation (Part 2, Water)

Reply

Kim January 11, 2012 at 10:32 pm

Alisa, you rock! I wish I could be half as self-aware as you. Thank you for putting this in a way that makes total sense (even though I now feel like a choad for my previous behavior). I’m saving this to re-read when I’m feeling overworked and under appreciated.

Reply

Edward January 11, 2012 at 11:27 pm

I have gotten away from keeping score, because there is nothing to win! I can win but at what cost? At the expense of dismantling my wife. I often say, “in marriage you can be right and still be wrong”. Don’t win, lose the argument and win their love. IMO.
Edward´s last [type] ..‘Til Death Do Us Part. Where is Your Marriage Headed?

Reply

Brian January 12, 2012 at 6:40 am

I lost the new puppy debate too! Outvoted 3-1. Of course I’m the one getting up in the middle of the night with him, picking up the poop, running home at lunch to let him out. Good thing he’s cute…

Reply

Alisa January 12, 2012 at 7:10 am

Brian–I commiserate! Today it’s raining and this puppy DOES NOT WANT TO GO OUTSIDE TO DO HER BUSINESS. Poor little thing. But still….

Renee January 12, 2012 at 8:27 am

Alisa, thank you for this post. My goal is to really work on my marriage in 2012 so I have been bending over backwards to do nice things for my husband in addition to all of the stuff I already do. I was feeling really good about being able to take care of him more but it wasn’t appreciated at all. That is what usually drives me to keep score. I find that my chores/tasks are ways for me to tell my husband and my family that I love them and when they don’t appreciate it that makes me feel unloved. This has been a struggle for me and at one time my best friend said that if I am doing it because I love them then why am I expecting anything in return? Do it for him/them or do it for me but not both. Guess I need to remember that more often.

Reply

Susan January 12, 2012 at 10:14 pm

Renee, have you read The Five Love Languages? Fascinating stuff! I’m no relationship specialist but it sounds like you experience love through acts of service, while your husband may feel it in other ways (perhaps spending time with him instead of doing things for him, for example).
Susan´s last [type] ..May I Pick Your Brain? The Classic Freelance Quandary

Reply

Renee January 12, 2012 at 10:17 pm

Yes, I have! Love it. I definitely SHOW love through service and it is becoming more evident that I receive it the same way – otherwise maybe this wouldn’t be such a big issue for me. Because really, I could not care less if he gets me gifts or not. Interesting. Thanks for reminding me.

JenP January 12, 2012 at 12:30 pm

I’m not in a relationship, but I’d like to be! Looking for Mr Right!
I have met someone I like. We’re good friends but reading your post, I was suddenly struck by how I keep a score of who has texted who. I often think, Oh, I’ll send him a text and see how his day went, and then I’ll remember that I texted him last and he still hasn’t replied. I wouldn’t behave like this with a friend who wasn’t an attractive man so I can’t think why I’m keeping score like this just because he is!

Reply

365 Acts of Love January 12, 2012 at 6:27 pm

If love keeps no score of wrongs (I Corinthians 13), perhaps it keeps no score of rights, either.

Reply

sophie January 13, 2012 at 11:24 am

This is such a great post! For most of us, not keeping score is a challenge…our egos keep us feeling like we are doing more and our partner somehow less. Sometimes, it is the case and I cannot help but keep a list in my head. I’ve finally started asking for help and what I need which is much more helpful.

Reply

Jason Anthony January 13, 2012 at 12:41 pm

I believe that the score-keeping game is the equivalent of a personal attack on someone’s character.

With the extreme cases excluded, saying “I did this more,” is just a passive way of pointing a finger and saying “you do this less,” and showing your discontent or resentment in a way. No good comes from it.

What the trick? Avoid focusing on “fair,” which is a fairy tale (and we all know it) and spend more energy focusing on what’s just, and right.
Jason Anthony´s last [type] ..Come On, Come On, Lets Work Together

Reply

Tanja Pajevic January 13, 2012 at 7:29 pm

I really like what you wrote about scarcity v. abundance–it inspired me to write a post about how our expectations tie in to the way we communicate. Here’s a link if you’d like to read about it: http://rebootthismarriage.com/2012/01/whats-your-communication-style-scarcity-or-abundance/
Thanks!
Tanja Pajevic
http://rebootthismarriage.com
Tanja Pajevic´s last [type] ..What’s Your Communication Style? Scarcity or Abundance?

Reply

sarah henry January 22, 2012 at 10:43 am

Everything you say here is wise and true — and I still hope the hubbie picks up the slack when he gets back from his trip. Will you write about that too?
sarah henry´s last [type] ..Cooking Breakfast at Bette’s Diner in Berkeley for 27 Years

Reply

I'd probably better stay anonymous for this one January 23, 2012 at 6:55 pm

This was, perhaps, my favorite post of yours, only because you nailed the issue that I have had for YEARS in my marriage. I have stayed married even while having a huge amount of resentment against my husband because I realize that I do keep score and keeping score is not a good thing. But what about, as your daughter so aptly pointed out, the fact that your spouse might just be LAZY?

How about that in the end, it’s not even about “he’s lazy, therefore he’s bad” and “I’m not lazy, therefore I’m good;” rather, it’s about “he’s lazy and therefore I am not attracted to him?” Or “therefore he doesn’t make me happy?”

I’ve stayed because I realize that I can’t make him a bad person just because he does less (in every aspect, including working outside of the home and earning money) — but what if, because of that reality, I just am not really attracted to him anymore?

Reply

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge

Previous post:

Next post: