My friend Mary threw a Gold Party over the weekend. At such parties, a guy with some fancy smantzy stuff (magnet, scale, acid, magnifying loop) looks at all of the old, gaudy, cruddy gold jewelry you no longer want and he offers you money for it. Since gold is the one investment still worth something in this economy, the women who attend these parties generally go home obscenely happy.
Seriously. I kid you not. One divorcee from Mary’s party cashed in engagement rings (minus the stones), wedding bands, and other regretful leftovers from her past. We all hooted and cheered when we learned that these old marital relics would allow her to go home $1300 richer.
I, however, went home penniless. I’ve never liked gold jewelry. The only gold pieces in my entire collection were gifts from others and, as I learned from Mr. Gold Man, none were really gold. They were all fakes, including my high school ring. That was a bummer because I think my parents spent a week’s paycheck on that thing and I’m not sure whether or not I ever wore it.
I wasn’t all that disappointed. I mean, $10 or $20 would have been nice, but I hadn’t gone to the party for the money. I’d gone for the wine, the food, and because Mary asked me to go, and I love Mary (as every good woman should).
When I arrived, Mary was the only woman I knew, but that quickly changed, especially once Mary told everyone about my blog. Soon, I knew about the ins and outs of the current and past relationships of nearly every woman in the room, and they knew about mine, too.
It was a great time.
Toward the end of the evening, though, a woman asked me a question that stopped me short. This single 35 year old asked, “If you could go back in time, would you marry your husband again? I mean, really, would you? I just wonder. I have a hard time believing in marriage. I just don’t believe in it.”
I think I said something to the effect of, “Um, well, wow, that’s a good question.”
As I stood there looking befuddled, somewhere in my brain there was a voice screaming, “Say ‘yes’ you idiot. Just say, ‘yes’!” And somewhere else in my brain there was another voice screaming, “But I owe her my honesty, and, well, I’m not sure. Would I?”
Then, I said a bunch of mumbo jumbo like, “I’m really glad we worked on things and I am happy to be married to him now. We’re stronger now than ever, but it’s hard for me to know what I would do. I’d like to think I would marry him again.”
As I said this, one of the voices was telling me, “If you could go back in time, you’d go on a wild dating spree, and you know it!” And the other voice was telling that voice to just shut up already.
So Would I?
I thought about her question as I drove home. I thought about it that night as I was falling asleep. I thought about it all weekend long. I thought about it so much that I’m writing about it today, on a day when I’d planned to write Part 2 of How to Face Your Biggest Fear. (No worries: that’s coming soon. Really, it is.)
And after spending two whole days pondering deep marital thoughts, I’ve decided that, yes, I would marry my husband all over again. I would because I am now a better person than I was 13 years ago when I met him, and I do believe he had something to do with my personal growth.
If my husband had not been the type of person who does not have a worry in the world, I would not have had the courage to leave my paying job at a national consumer magazine and go freelance.
If he had not been a beer connoisseur, I would have never discovered my love of hops and I’d probably still be drinking Amstel Light instead of any craft beer with the phrase “hops explosion” in its name.
If he had not also loved to travel and eat, I probably would not have tasted octopus in Greece, fish gills in Turkey, roti in Dominica, or lingonberries in Finland.
If he had not been such a colossal slacker, I would never have developed my assertive voice.
Yes, indeed, my husband’s so-called faults are what forced me to become a better, stronger, happier person. If he had been the type of man who doted on me and catered to my every need, I could have remained meek. If he had been the type of man who earned millions, I could have remained too scared to excel in my career. If he had been a Type A worry-a-holic like me, I’m sure we’d both been addicted to some sort of tranquilizers by now.
And if he hadn’t have been so God forsaken stubborn, I’d never have had the sweet satisfaction that comes from seeing him eventually come around to my point of view.
For example, for years my husband and I have bickered about the proper way to fold the laundry. He takes things out of the dryer and makes one huge pile. I’ve very nicely asked him on more than one occasion if he wouldn’t mind sorting the clothes into categories rather than putting them all together in one big lump. My reasoning was this: it’s much easier to take an entire pile of underwear and stick it in a drawer all at once than it is to take one item at a time off a huge pile, put that one item away, and return to the huge pile to get the next item. I also thought the pile sorting would prevent the common occurrence of me finding our daughter’s little socks mixed in with my panties.
His response to this request was: Fat chance.
Seriously. This is the man I live with.
Until recently, I solved our little laundry war by asking our cleaning lady, who comes once a week, to sort through my husband’s big lump of a pile and put the clothes away for me. I figured she was getting paid for her frustration.
Well, recently money got a bit tight, so we had to let the cleaning lady go. On this sad day, my husband and I sat down and split up all of the cleaning tasks. I took the kitchen, bathroom and dining room. He got the rest of the house. He also got the job of putting away the folded clothes.
The other day, I walked into the basement in search of a pair of clean underwear. Do you want to know what I found? Numerous nicely folded piles of clothes is what I found! My shirts were in one pile, my exercise clothes in another, and my underwear in yet another. Our daughter’s clothes had their own pile, too.
It was folded laundry nirvana. It nearly took my breath away. I stood and stared at this miracle on Earth for a good 60 seconds.
With a humongous grin, I took two of the piles upstairs with me and put them away.
I did not tell my husband about this discovery, mind you. I did not gloat outwardly in any way. I didn’t have to. It felt incredible to be proven right after so many years of him telling me that my laundry system was wrong.
If he had not been such a stubborn person, I would never have experienced this satisfaction.
You see? He has both been one of my life’s greatest challenges as well as one of my life’s greatest rewards. Marriage is the second hardest thing I’ve ever done, with parenthood being the hardest. But, just as I would never go back in time and undo my decision to become a mother, I also would not undo my decision to become a wife.
Yes, I would marry that pain in the ass stubborn slacker all over again. It would be an honor.
If you could go back in time, would you still marry your spouse? Why or why not? Leave a comment.
Copyright 2009 Project Happily Ever After
No related posts.
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.








{ 9 comments… read them below or add one }
I find this post especially meaningful because I’ve just gone through the hardest year of our marriage so far, which included us separating and him moving out for 5 months. Even though there were times I thought I was in so much pain dying would be easier… when I look back over this year, I figured out exactly what you’ve said… I grew as a person so much that I wouldn’t take back any of that time and even though it was hard to stay committed, I’m really glad that I’m still married.
A wise older friend once told me two important things about marriage… she was 85 and had been married for 60+ years. She said the secret to a lasting marriage was simply showing up… each and every day, even when you don’t really want to. And she told me that the real purpose of marriage is to rub off our rough edges; she said that when we think we’re fixing our partner is exactly the time that WE are being fixed!
Another great post Alison!
Where is the “give me a few days to furrow my brow on this one” option? Of course I answered yes, on the off-chance my wife reads this and ask (or just asks out of blue, which oftentimes is the case). Is it possible to say you might have pondered a different course? After all, you really didn’t know what being married to someone was like until you actually married them. Hence, how could you have known what you were missing? It also raises the larger question: Is there room for dissent without threatening love? With my own experience to draw upon, I can clearly say that in the first two instances, I very much would’ve avoided the institution of marriage. Obviously. But this time, it’s based on a much different and stronger foundation. I know, blah, blah — quit waffling. But it is one of those great keep-it-to-yourself ponderables. Thanks again, Bauman/Bowman.
Since it’s too late for us married old people, my question is: would you wish a character strengthening man for your daughter to marry/be with, or a doting, money earning man?
Mollie,
At first I thought your question was going to make me think for three days and then reconsider my entire blog post. Then, in like 30 seconds, I knew my answer. I would want whatever situation makes her happiest. I can’t guess which way that would go for her. Will she grow up to be more like me where she really loves personal growth? I’m really an odd duck. I understand if she ends up way different than me!
There’s something that keeps me in my marriage that I’ve had a hard time describing in words as long as I’ve been blogging. I think it’s a central tension. Without it, I’d be bored. My daughter might not get bored with a marriage that lacks tension. I would respect that.
In the end, I just want her to know herself and have the courage to be
herself and love herself. I want a man who loves her for that and, if he doesn’t, I hope she has the courage to tell him to pack his bags.
As much as I complain and make fun of my husband, I do know, without a doubt, that he both loves me and would be eternally lost without me. He’s just a collassal pain in the butt sometimes, but that’s what keeps things interesting for me.
I love this post and have thought about this very question many times in my life. I come to the same conclusion as you do. I would be the person I am proud of being today if it were not for him-the whole package-him. It is the idiosyncracies in my husband that I love and hate that brought out the best in me and taught me many things in this life. I also complain about him and wish I were single sometimes. I am 15 years into our life together and wish for that butterfly feeling sometimes, but then I come to the realization that I picked a winner no matter how you look at it
I told a friend today that getting married at 36 is probably the hardest thing I’ve ever done, simply because I spent so much time coming and going and crafting good and bad habits all of my very own before he came along and made me aware of them. Compromise is a hard lesson to learn after so many years. It doesn’t help that I married my polar opposite, but he shows me ways of being that have stretched me beyond my wildest imagination. I do wish it weren’t so painful to break old habits, though, and am mildly jealous of people who gush when they talk about their spouses and marriage. But life is way better with him than without. I know that for certain.
I am a newly-wed….so the question for me wasn’t so much “would I marry him again?” as it was: “what I say YES to his asking me to marry him again?” And the answer is YES! No because he’s perfect or easy, but because he DOES teach me. He does make me grow and learn–and face myself in a way that NO ONE else ever has! Yes, it’s insanely annoying and frustrating at times; but, in reality, WHEN is life ever truly easy? I don’t think it is. But it IS totally worth it–always! At least in my own life!
Alisa, I think your post about your daughter is right on! I think wanting her to love herself and accept herself as she is and supporting WHATEVER she wants for her own happiness is MAJORLY ADMIRABLE! You put it so wonderfully!
Also, I shared this post with my married friends–and they completely agreed with you (Alisa)! They also lauhged their butts off because pretty much everything in here, as usual, is so darn true!
I liked this particular post so much that I printed it out and put in our wedding scrapbook….because I KNOW darn good and well that this is a MARRIAGE…that will NOT always be easy and cakes and roses! But, I hope and pray, every day (I also work at it too!) that in 10, 20, 30 years…I too can say, YES…I would marry him all over again, and like Alisa said, it truly would be my honor!
So, thank you Alisa, for the laughs and the inspiration! And for your genuine honesty! And also, for putting a positive spin on those not so great aspect about men/husbands/married life!
Marital Blessings Always,
-Sarah Liz
Oddly enough, no men answered this question.
No. I would miss my younger son, but really this person just brings out the worst in me. He is a passive aggressive slacker. We don’t want the same things out of life and after 18 years and pressure from my family I know I settled. I wasn’t smart and I wasn’t lucky. I thought I was running out of time at 32. I am bored and disappointed. Did I mention that he lost his job two years ago and has been up my ass ever since? I was downsized five years ago. Money is tight and I wish I had married someone who has good taste and ambition. I just need to vent. If he was back at work full time out of the house with healthcare benefits,things would be a lot better.